Bobby Cutts Clues in Detail

This post is a continuation/expansion on this post which was written before Bobby Cutts, Jr. was arrested.

What are some of the other clues that hinted to me that Cutts wasn’t being honest?

1. Cutts tone-of-voice when he said the words “No, I did not” when asked by Todd Porter if he had anything to do with the disappearance of Jessie Davis. More than just the tone, it was the lack of stressing enunciation in the presentation of the words, if that makes sense. When someone says something definitively, there is a stressing of the words when one is confident of what they are saying. When Cutts said “No, I did not”, he said it mousy, weak and without conviction.

   For a comparison — right after that when Cutts was asked if he had an attorney –Cutts puts confidence behind his statement when he says the word “yes”. There is more behind that word then when he said “no”. Yet the more serious question was by far the first one where the stakes were exceptionally high. We should have heard a strong enunciative response. We didn’t and that difference clued me in, and raised my eyebrows.

2. When I listened to Cutts talk, I tried to understand what he was saying– by making logical sense out of the words he was speaking. When he said the following, I tried to figure out what scenario would make this statement make sense.
   

   “The past five …five days.. have been a like nightmare that that …won’t end, like…every…every second of it , I mean when it seems like it’s turning… and gonna change… it goes back to same, or it gets worse … its different…the way I’ve been…. betrayed and just, I mean I haven’t been myself. I…I can’t sleep. I can’t eat. Anybody that knows me knows me that if I’m normal joking around and laughing…trying to have fun and make everyone else laugh and…it’s juss….just been hell.”

   If I plugged into the equation the what-if-he-did-this-scenario — it all seemed to add up. He was upset that he was being looked at as a suspect — and the stress of being looked at as a suspect was overwhelming him. When the police looked at him closely and then retreated again — it was a living hell for him. He was falling apart wondering if and when the dam was going to break — and the uncertainty of it all was driving him insane. It would make sense why he couldn’t eat or sleep — and why Jessie wasn’t the focus of his thoughts. Cutts was breaking under the pressure and this fit with his behavior and words — and actions — to a tee. Every other scenario I plugged in had inconsistencies.

3. When Bobby Cutts said he “tried” not to watch the news stories on TV about Jessie Davis — that raised my eyebrows as well. If you are seriously distraught over your missing girlfriend and had nothing to do with her disappearance, you either do or do not watch. You have strong emotions that dictate your actions one-way or another — but you don’t waffle and and “try” not too. I suspects Cutts was afraid to watch it on TV because it would make him go even more crazy — but at times, he couldn’t resist the temptation to hear what was going on — hence he “tried” not too.
4. When Cuts was asked how many children he had, he stuttered when he asked back “Currently?”. That really got the hair on the back of my neck to stand up. If you have nothing to do with your expected-child’s disappearance, you don’t question “Currently?”. You can interview 100s of people who are innocent and you won’t hear that. The reason I suspect for this is that the pain of accepting the loss of the expectant child is too great for an innocent person — so they stay in the current of what they last knew — until something changes. Innocent people who face a loss like this hang on to every shred of hope they can before conceding it is over.

   Furthermore, Cutts backed it up again when he answered Todd Porter’s question if he had a fourth child on the way with Jessie. Cutts said “Possibly, yes”. Again, for an innocent person — the words “possibly” would NEVER enter into their mind. They would be hanging on to every shred of hope they could muster. But when someone has something to do with harming someone, they often “distance” themselves from things.

5. Bobby acted completely distraught far beyond what everyone else was. That was a red flag in itself. While there are scenarios where people will react differently — and emotionally out-of-the-norm and could still be totally uninvolved, we would expect to see behavioral patterns that support the emotions. With Cutts, I did not.

To come to these conclusions, it’s important I share with you that I am constantly doing a balancing act between what is said, how a person is behaving, feeling and acting. Alone a piece of information may be potentially logical — but in a puzzle, a square piece will never fit in a round hole.